Producer Na Young Seok has drawn significant criticism following the airing of the special variety show, “Reply 1988 10th Anniversary,” which premiered on March 19, 2024. This program, designed to celebrate the tenth anniversary of the beloved drama Reply 1988, featured many key actors from the original cast, including Ryu Jun Yeol, Hyeri, and Park Bo Gum. While the show aimed to rekindle the nostalgia of fans, it has sparked a divided response among viewers regarding the focus of its content.
The anniversary special showcased a one-night, two-day trip that brought together the stars who defined the Reply 1988 phenomenon. Viewers initially reacted positively to the warm interactions, casual conversations, and games among the cast. However, as the show progressed, many began to voice their disappointment over the excessive screen time given to the production team rather than the actors themselves.
Critics highlighted that the show deviated from standard variety formats by heavily featuring producers Na Young Seok and Shin Won Ho. One viewer remarked, “Unlike typical variety shows that focus on the cast, the camera closely captured the production team and gave significant screen time to their reactions.” This editorial choice led to a perception that the production team was prioritized over the actors, undermining the intended celebration of the cast’s reunion.
The editing particularly drew ire, as it contrasted the experiences of PD Shin Won Ho, who was adapting to the variety show environment, against that of Na Young Seok. Viewers noted that this imbalance made the production team more visible than the actors, which detracted from the immersive experience of the show. Raw audio from the production team during game segments was aired without editing, prompting further complaints that it hindered the audience’s ability to engage fully with the cast.
This is not the first time Na Young Seok has faced scrutiny for his directorial choices. His previous works have often included the production team as prominent characters, a decision some viewers appreciate as a unique aspect of his programs. Nonetheless, there remains a persistent criticism regarding the extent of producer exposure in his shows.
Given the high anticipation surrounding the reunion of the actors for this special, analysts suggest that the production team’s significant involvement may have backfired. Viewer expectations for an intimate celebration of the beloved series clashed with the reality of a show that placed the spotlight on its creators rather than its stars. This divisive reception may prompt future considerations regarding the balance of focus between cast and crew in upcoming productions.
