The season 3 finale of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives aired on November 13, 2024, revealing a surprising twist in the relationship between stars Chase McWhorter and Taylor Frankie Paul. Following a tumultuous romantic history, including a controversial “soft-swinging” scandal, the two met for lunch where they revisited their past and even flirted about sharing a kiss. This moment marks a significant shift in their dynamic, considering their previous conflicts.
The backdrop of their relationship is complicated. Before the series premiered in September 2024, Taylor became embroiled in a scandal involving “soft swinging” while still married to Tate Paul. This affair led to tensions between Taylor and Miranda McWhorter, Chase’s then-wife. Taylor expressed her feelings during season 2, stating, “Her husband was the one [who] had feelings for me,” emphasizing that her actions were misunderstood.
Chase and Miranda wed in 2017 and welcomed two children, Brooks in 2019 and Cohen in 2021, but their marriage ended in 2024. Chase later reflected to Us Weekly about their separation, saying, “I think we both realized that we’d gotten married a little prematurely.” Despite the breakup, he noted they maintain a friendly relationship for the sake of their children.
In the finale, Chase shocked Taylor by announcing he had “technically broken up” with Kate Racker just days before. Their lunch turned into a nostalgic discussion about their feelings for each other. “Honestly, Taylor, I always thought you were one of the coolest people ever,” Chase remarked. Taylor acknowledged her flirtatious nature, suggesting the chemistry between them remains strong.
The series has garnered attention for its portrayal of unconventional relationships, but the fallout from the soft-swinging scandal remains a topic of contention. Chase explained, “It all started during COVID… a bunch of our friends coming—couples—and then we’d all get trashed on alcohol.” He clarified that the activities were often misrepresented, stating, “It was never predetermined that we were going to be doing, like, swinging.”
Since the airing of the show, Taylor has continued to rise to prominence, recently being cast as the lead in The Bachelorette. This development raises questions about her future connections with Chase, as the series concluded with a playful suggestion from him to kiss “for old times’ sake.”
Chase’s involvement in the show has also led to friction with other cast members. His podcast, “OnlyDads,” has drawn criticism, particularly from fellow cast member Mayci Neeley, who referred to him as a “scumbag” for comments made regarding personal losses she experienced.
The unfolding narratives within The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives continue to captivate audiences, blending personal drama with the complexities of modern relationships. As both Chase and Taylor navigate their past and present, viewers are left to ponder the implications of their rekindled connection amid the backdrop of their public lives.
