Portsmouth’s Commonwealth’s Attorney, Stephanie Morales, is seeking a third full term in office amid a competitive election featuring two challengers. Local attorneys Nathan Chapman and Steve Heretick are challenging the incumbent, asserting that her office has committed numerous errors that have impacted the judicial process.
Morales, a 41-year-old Democrat, has faced criticism for her office’s handling of several high-profile cases. Notably, multiple cases, including serious murder charges, were dismissed by judges due to procedural missteps. These included missing filing deadlines and failing to furnish necessary information to the defense. Among the notable dismissals was a murder case last year, where a judge ruled that prosecutors violated the defendant’s right to a speedy trial. Additionally, all charges against a man accused of killing four individuals at a Portsmouth boarding house were dropped when a judge found insufficient evidence presented by the prosecution.
Challenges within Morales’ office have grown, with her staff operating at approximately half the capacity it is funded for. This staffing shortage has raised concerns about the quality of legal representation and the overall efficiency of the office. Two prosecutors within her team have also faced multiple suspensions of their law licenses. Chapman highlighted this issue, stating, “The staffing issue is a very serious problem. She can’t get people to work there because the office’s reputation is so bad.”
While Morales acknowledges these “staffing challenges,” she noted that other Commonwealth’s Attorney offices in the Hampton Roads area are fully staffed. Morales has communicated her commitment to improving recruitment and retention efforts through various initiatives, including training and mentorship programs in partnership with law schools.
In response to the criticisms regarding dismissed cases, Morales emphasized her office’s ongoing efforts to enhance prosecution methods. “As with any public institution, continuous improvement is essential. We are consistently working to strengthen internal systems, enhance training, and expand the tools available to our attorneys and staff,” she stated in an email.
Heretick, who has served as a Portsmouth City Council member and state delegate, expressed his discontent with the mistakes occurring within Morales’ office. “These are very basic mistakes that should never happen,” he remarked, adding that no other Commonwealth’s Attorney office in Virginia is experiencing similar levels of case dismissals.
Morales, defending her team’s competence, stated, “I remain proud of the professionalism and dedication of my team. Prosecutors must handle complex cases with precision, and while outcomes may vary, we will never compromise our duty to pursue justice ethically and responsibly.”
The election also highlights endorsements that reflect the candidates’ standing within the community. Chapman’s campaign has garnered support from the local Fraternal Order of Police and the Police Benevolent Association, while Heretick has received backing from several notable local politicians, including Vice Mayor Bill Moody and former Vice Mayor Elizabeth Psimas. Morales, in turn, has secured endorsements from prominent state leaders, including Virginia House Speaker Don Scott and U.S. Rep. Bobby Scott.
In terms of fundraising, Morales leads the pack with over $97,000 raised this year, according to the Virginia Public Access Project. Heretick closely follows with $87,000, despite entering the race in May, while Chapman has raised $21,000.
Both challengers emphasize their commitment to addressing the staffing issues within the office, as well as rebuilding relationships with law enforcement and the community. Heretick remarked, “Portsmouth has a reputation as a dangerous city, and we’ve got to address that.” Chapman echoed similar sentiments, highlighting the need for dedicated staff and resources to tackle critical issues such as asset seizure from convicted criminals and addressing juvenile violence.
If elected to another term, Morales aims to expand crime prevention programs, increase support for victims, and enhance case management through improved technology. Each candidate presents a unique perspective on how to enhance the effectiveness of the Commonwealth’s Attorney’s office, making this election a pivotal moment for Portsmouth’s legal landscape.
As the election draws near, the outcomes of these campaigns could significantly shape the future of prosecutorial practices in Portsmouth and impact community relations with law enforcement.
