Netflix has debuted its latest series, His & Hers, on January 8, 2026, featuring actors Tessa Thompson and Jon Bernthal. This six-part adaptation of Alison Feeney‘s crime novel follows an investigative journalist and a police detective who find themselves at odds while solving a murder mystery, complicated by their romantic past.
Critical reception has been mixed, with reviewers voicing a range of opinions about the show’s execution. While some critics praise its unique take on familiar themes, others find it lacking depth. As the first significant release of the year, His & Hers is generating considerable buzz in the television landscape.
Critical Reactions: Divided Opinions
Beginning with positive assessments, Michael Peyton from IGN awarded the series a remarkable score of 9 out of 10. He noted that the show starts as a typical murder mystery but evolves into a profound exploration of grief, marriage, and parenthood, maintaining viewer engagement throughout.
In a similarly enthusiastic review, Aramide Tinubu from Variety described His & Hers as “deliciously bonkers,” labeling it one of television’s most unhinged offerings. Even Lucy Mangan from The Guardian found it binge-worthy, giving it a score of 3.5 out of 5. Mangan characterized it as “comfort television” that suits early-year viewing, though she also remarked on the increasing absurdities and the script’s limitations.
Conversely, other critics voiced dissatisfaction. Reuben Baron from Looper commented on the show’s shock value but critiqued its lack of intellectual substance. Daniel Fienberg from The Hollywood Reporter expressed disappointment in the chemistry between Thompson and Bernthal, while Judy Berman from Time Magazine called it “too grim to be fun, too silly to take seriously.”
A Shocking Twist Unites Critics
Despite the varied feedback, one element of the series resonates with all reviewers: the shocking finale. Without revealing any spoilers, critics described a significant twist that leaves viewers astounded. Tinubu shared her experience of watching the conclusion, stating, “I literally sat in shock, screaming ‘WHAT?!!’ continually.” Peyton added that the finale achieves the rare feat of making one ponder long after the credits roll.
Overall, while opinions on the series may vary, the unexpected ending seems to be a common talking point, suggesting that His & Hers is worth tuning in for, if only to witness its remarkable conclusion. The series is currently available for streaming on Netflix, giving viewers the opportunity to form their own opinions.
